Key takeaways
- Most tax resolution cases run two payment plans at once: the client's IRS installment agreement or offer, and your firm's fee plan, both paid from the same budget.
- The fee plan is the one clients dispute, often when debits keep landing through months with no visible progress on the case.
- Visa consumer disputes for services can be filed 120 days from the charge or from the date services were expected, up to 540 days, so old payments stay exposed after a case closes.
- Bill in stages tied to documented work, keep card installments free of interest with any late fee kept flat, and take Truth in Lending and Circular 230 fee questions to counsel.
- Each rail has its own authorization rule: Visa's stored-credential consent for cards, a signed or similarly authenticated authorization plus a copy for ACH, and express verifiable authorization for bank debits in telemarketing the TSR covers.
- ACH removes card dispute rights, not disputes: clients can return debits as unauthorized for up to 60 days on claims such as R11, and Nacha watches a 0.5% unauthorized return rate.
Most tax resolution payment plans are really two plans. One is the client's deal with the IRS: an installment agreement, or the payments that come with an offer in compromise. The other is your firm's fee, split into monthly installments while the case works. The client pays both out of the same budget, often in the same month.
The fee plan is the one that turns into disputes, often because billing runs ahead of work the client can see. A client who keeps paying month after month without hearing what changed starts to wonder what the money buys, and their bank gives them several ways to ask for it back.
Below: how to structure, authorize, communicate and cancel a fee plan so it finishes, under the rules as of November 2026. This is general information, not legal or tax advice: talk to your attorney or CPA about your own firm.
Most tax resolution cases have two payment plans
According to the IRS payment plans page (updated August 13, 2026), an individual can apply online for a long-term plan if they owe $50,000 or less in combined tax, penalties and interest and have filed all required returns, or for a short-term plan if they owe less than $100,000 and can pay within 180 days (older guides still say 120).
A short-term plan has no setup fee; a long-term plan costs $29 online with direct debit or $69 online otherwise, more by phone, mail or in person, and less for low-income taxpayers. Interest and some penalties keep running: the failure-to-pay penalty is 0.5% a month, capped at 25% (0.25% during an approved plan for an individual who filed on time), and interest is 7% a year, compounded daily, for the fourth quarter of 2026.
Unless the applicant qualifies as low-income, an offer in compromise needs a $205 application fee plus either 20% of a lump-sum offer or the first of continuing periodic payments, and the fee isn't returned if the offer is rejected.
Where your fee plan fits
When the IRS works out what a taxpayer can afford, its Financial Analysis Handbook (IRM 5.15.1) can allow fees for representation before the IRS, but says the amount "should not be excessive and must be reasonable given the complexity of the case."
| IRS plan or offer | Your fee plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets the terms | The IRS, under published rules | You, in the engagement letter |
| How it gets challenged | IRS processes, such as appealing a rejected offer | Card disputes and bank returns, sometimes months later |
| Rules that govern it | IRS procedures | Card network and Nacha rules, Regulation E, the Telemarketing Sales Rule for covered telemarketing, Circular 230 for practitioners |
Why fee plans turn into disputes
Tax cases move on the IRS's timeline. An offer can stay pending for up to two years, and to the client that stretch looks like silence while the debits keep landing.
The FTC and Nevada's October 2025 complaint against American Tax Service shows the pattern at its worst. It alleges telemarketers offered to "spread the fees out on a monthly payment plan," clients heard nothing "for weeks or months at a time," and refund requests were often refused. Those are allegations, not findings, though two operators settled in June 2026; the FTC's announcement cites a $77.7 million judgment, suspended once the two surrender over $8 million in cash plus other assets, and bans on debt relief services, tax preparation and nearly all outbound telemarketing.
The dispute reasons that show up
Many fee-plan disputes aren't fraud claims, because the client knows they signed up. Under the Visa Core Rules (October 2026 edition), consumer disputes come with long windows.
| Visa dispute | What the client is saying | Time limit |
|---|---|---|
| 13.1 Merchandise/Services Not Received | I paid and nothing happened | 120 days from the charge or the expected service date, up to 540 days |
| 13.2 Cancelled Recurring Transaction | I cancelled and you kept charging | 120 days from the charge |
| 13.5 Misrepresentation | That isn't what I was told | 120 days from the charge or from receiving the services, up to 540 days |
| 13.7 Cancelled Merchandise/Services | I cancelled and never got my refund | 120 days, up to 540 days, after a 15-day wait |
Visa applies Misrepresentation to card-absent merchants that say they reduce or amend existing financial products (such as debt consolidation and credit repair) and to outbound telemarketing, judged by what is sold, not the merchant code. Tax debt isn't listed, so ask your acquirer how it treats your sales. Either way, a month-two payment can be disputed long after the case closes.
Offer expectations vs IRS data
Misrepresentation turns on what the client was told before paying. The IRS Data Book shows 38,797 offers proposed and 5,464 accepted in fiscal 2025 (different cohorts, so not an acceptance rate), and the IRS's 2026 Dirty Dozen list warns that "OIC mills" often overpromise results. If your pitch makes an offer sound likely, your fee plan inherits that promise.
Structure the fee around work you can show
Visa's merchant dispute guide is blunt: "Do not charge for services or goods you cannot yet deliver." For a resolution case, tie each payment to a stage the client can see.
- An investigation fee that buys a deliverable, such as transcripts pulled and a written assessment, whether or not you take the case.
- A resolution fee billed in stages, each tied to a documented milestone: financials prepared and signed, the request or offer submitted, the IRS response answered.
- A record for every stage. Visa lists service logs and signed acknowledgments as evidence that services were received.
On a Visa Partial Payment (an interest-free installment series agreed by the first charge) you may not charge interest, and any late fee must be flat. Only certain categories, such as travel or custom goods and services, may take an Advance Payment of the entire price before delivery, so ask your acquirer before charging a full multi-month fee on day one.
Questions to take to counsel
- Truth in Lending. Under Regulation Z, a "creditor" regularly (more than 25 times) extends consumer credit with a finance charge or payable by written agreement in more than four installments, not counting a down payment. A fee owed at signing and paid in five or more installments can raise the question; pay-as-you-go stages may not create deferred debt.
- Autopay. If a plan is credit, Regulation E bars making preauthorized transfers a condition of it. Offering autopay is different from requiring it.
- Circular 230. Section 10.27 bars an "unconscionable fee" and bars contingent fees on IRS matters except in a few cases, none covering offers or installment agreements. Reimbursing the client if a position isn't sustained, through "a guarantee" or a similar arrangement, counts as a contingent fee, so a money-back-if-rejected promise needs review. Refunds for work not done are different.
Hypothetical: a staged plan
Say a client owes the IRS $38,000 and you quote $500 for the investigation and $3,000 to negotiate an installment agreement. Here are two ways to bill the same $3,500 on the same made-up timeline.
| When | What the client can see | Plan A: 12 equal debits | Plan B: staged |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signing | Engagement letter signed | $500 plus $250 | $500 |
| Month 1 | Transcripts and written assessment | $250 | $0 |
| Month 2 | Financial statement signed | $250 | $1,000 |
| Month 3 | Installment agreement request submitted | $250 | $1,000 |
| Months 4-7 | Waiting on the IRS | $1,000 ($250 a month) | $0 |
| Month 8 | Agreement in place | $250 | $1,000 |
| Months 9-11 | Client making IRS payments | $750 ($250 a month) | $0 |
Plan A takes $1,000 in four months when nothing visible happened, then keeps debiting after the IRS agreement starts: at $500 a month to the IRS, the client pays $750 a month for three months. Its 12 installments also raise the Truth in Lending question. Plan B asks for bigger payments (a stage can be split across two debits), but no debit lands in a month with nothing to show.
Get authorization that holds up
Each payment rail has its own rule for proving what the client agreed to.
Cards
Before storing a card for future charges, Visa requires the cardholder's express informed consent to terms including the services, total price, cancellation and refund policies, and the amount, timing and frequency of charges. They must be shown at the moment of consent, separately from your general terms, and kept for the life of the agreement. A payment clause on page six of an engagement letter is unlikely to count as separate.
ACH
Recurring debits from a consumer's account "may be authorized only by a writing signed or similarly authenticated by the consumer," and the client gets a copy (Regulation E ยง1005.10). Nacha's sample authorization adds the amount or range, the dates or frequency and, for recurring debits, how and with how much notice the client can revoke. Keep it for two years after it ends.
Phone sales
When a phone sale is telemarketing the Telemarketing Sales Rule covers (outbound calls, and some inbound ones; many inbound calls answering general ads are exempt, so ask counsel where your calls fall), a bank debit needs "express verifiable authorization": a signed writing, a recorded oral authorization covering the number, dates and amounts of the debits among other details, or written confirmation sent by first-class mail before you bill. The TSR also bars remotely created payment orders and cash-to-cash money transfers as payment, even on exempt inbound calls, and requires five years of records.
The advance-fee ban
The TSR's debt relief advance-fee ban reaches tax debt relief on paper: the rule text has no tax carve-out. In 2010 the FTC said that "until further notice" it would defer enforcing the debt relief amendments, advance-fee ban included, against services that alter "a tax obligation between a person and a taxing entity" (FTC enforcement policy), and we found no notice ending that as of November 2026. The statement says those services remain subject to the rest of the TSR and the FTC Act, and state law can apply too. The deferral binds only the FTC: the Telemarketing Act lets state attorneys general bring TSR cases themselves.
Cards or ACH for installments
ACH is often pitched as the dispute-free option. It removes card dispute rights, not disputes.
| Card installments | ACH installments | |
|---|---|---|
| How a client reverses a payment | A dispute with their card issuer | An unauthorized return through their bank |
| How long they have | 120 days for most consumer disputes, up to 540 where services were due later | 60 days for consumer claims such as R11 |
| What gets measured | Network monitoring programs, such as Visa's VAMP | Return rates: 0.5% unauthorized, 3.0% administrative, 15.0% overall |
| Over a long case | Cards expire and get reissued | Unaffected by card reissues |
R11 means the client says a debit wasn't "in accordance with the terms of the authorization," and it counts toward the 0.5% unauthorized rate along with R07 (authorization revoked) and R10. Since June 2026, Nacha's fraud monitoring rule requires every business originator to have risk-based processes reasonably intended to identify entries initiated due to fraud, including entries that may be unauthorized or authorized under false pretenses.
On cards, Visa's monitoring ratio counts fraud reports plus disputes against card-not-present sales, and Visa lowered its merchant threshold in 2026, so get current levels from your acquirer (our chargebacks hub covers the math). 3-D Secure's liability shift and Visa's Compelling Evidence 3.0 both target fraud disputes, so neither does much for a fee plan.
Keep the client informed between debits
Disputes are least likely when the client already knows what is happening. Send a short status note before each debit and while the case waits. Here is a made-up three-line note for the Plan B client above, sent in month 5:
What happened: We submitted your installment agreement request to the IRS on March 12.
What's next: We're waiting on the IRS and will contact you when it responds.
Next debit: None until the agreement is in place. The final $1,000 stage is charged then.
Regulation E lets a client stop a recurring ACH debit by telling their bank three business days ahead, and the first you hear may be a return. Send the note about five business days before a debit, so the client can call you before they call the bank.
- Notice when an amount changes. For a recurring ACH debit whose amount varies, Regulation E generally requires written notice of the amount and date 10 days ahead.
- Pause when the IRS pauses, and tell the client before you pause and again before you resume.
- Keep it in writing. Visa's guide says verbal explanations don't count in a dispute response unless they can be documented.
Cancellation, refunds and the engagement letter
Visa's dispute guide lists installment plans under Cancelled Recurring (13.2), though outside Europe the Core Rules apply 13.2 to recurring transactions, so ask your acquirer how your plan is flagged. Either way, the guide advises: make cancelling easy, confirm it in writing with the effective date, stop billing right after that date, and keep records. In a 13.2 the issuer certifies the date the client withdrew permission, so your own record of that date matters.
For recurring transactions, Visa also requires a simple cancellation procedure, online if the client signed up online, and for stored-card and installment payments it says the merchant "must refund the full amount paid" if it hasn't kept to the terms of the sale.
Engagement letter checklist
- What the investigation fee buys, including if you decline the case.
- Each billing stage and the milestone that triggers it.
- The schedule, the payment method, and how the client hears about changes or pauses.
- How to cancel and when cancellation takes effect.
- A refund formula for work not yet performed.
- What you will do, with no promise about what the IRS will decide.
- A separate payment authorization for each rail, with a copy to the client.
Applied to Plan B above, the refund formula is simple: a client who cancels in month 5 has paid $2,500 for the investigation and two completed stages, so nothing is refunded and the final $1,000 is never charged.
Have counsel review it against the fee rules that apply to you, including Circular 230 if you are a practitioner and state law where you sell.
How Flux fits
Flux runs card and ACH payments through one integration and works with high-risk and specialty merchants like tax relief firms. A person reviews every application, and not every business qualifies.
- Recurring billing charges a saved payment method on schedule, retries failed payments automatically and gives clients a secure link to update expired cards. Plans can be paused when a case stalls; to change one, cancel it and send a payment link for the new plan.
- The card capture form stores a card tokenized without charging it, and nothing is charged until you charge it from the dashboard or the API. A stage can also be billed by invoice or payment link.
- ACH debits can be charged or scheduled from the dashboard, settle in 3-5 business days (cards in 1-2) and are priced case by case.
- Webhooks report each card installment to your case system, and firms on Forth can collect inside Forth with the Set Forth integration.
Status notes, authorization wording and compliance stay with your firm and counsel. Software companies serving tax resolution firms can work with Flux through its referral and partner program: each referred firm applies to Flux, a person reviews it, and an approved firm gets its own Flux account. Flux runs the payments, security and support, and the software can build on the Flux API, hosted fields and payment links. Email support@fluxpayments.com.
Frequently asked questions
Is a tax resolution payment plan the same as an IRS installment agreement?
No. The IRS agreement pays the tax debt, while the firm's plan pays the firm's fee. Clients often carry both at once, so both have to fit the same budget.
Can a tax resolution firm charge its fees in monthly installments?
Generally yes, though state law can add limits for tax relief companies. Bill against work you can document, keep card installments free of interest with any late fee kept flat, and ask counsel whether a plan of more than four installments raises Truth in Lending questions.
Does the FTC's advance-fee ban apply to tax relief companies?
In 2010 the FTC deferred enforcement of the Telemarketing Sales Rule's debt relief amendments, including the advance-fee ban, for tax debt relief services "until further notice," and we found no notice ending that as of November 2026. That deferral binds only the FTC: state attorneys general can still enforce the TSR, and its other provisions, the FTC Act and state laws can apply, so ask counsel how they reach your firm.
Is ACH better than cards for tax resolution payment plans?
ACH isn't affected by card reissues and carries no card dispute rights, but clients can still return debits as unauthorized, for up to 60 days on claims such as R11, and Nacha watches a 0.5% unauthorized return rate. You can offer both, each with its own authorization.
How long can a client dispute a card payment for tax resolution services?
Under Visa's rules most consumer disputes must be filed within 120 days, but for services not yet provided the clock can start at the date the services were expected, up to 540 days after the charge.
Can a tax resolution firm offer a money-back guarantee if the IRS rejects an offer?
For practitioners under Circular 230, a promise to refund the fee if a position isn't sustained can count as a contingent fee, which isn't allowed for offers or installment agreements. Refund terms for work not performed are different, so have counsel review any guarantee.
Related reading
Billing tax resolution clients over a long case?
Flux runs card installments, scheduled ACH debits, plans you can pause and card-on-file capture through one integration. Tell us about your firm and a real person will review it.
Get Started